Has Crypto Left Privacy Behind?

Cypherpunk Guild
4 min readSep 19, 2023

In the early days of crypto, privacy was one of its most vaunted features. Cryptocurrencies, with Bitcoin at the forefront, promised a more decentralized financial system where transactions could be made without the oversight of banks or government bodies. However, as the crypto landscape has evolved, privacy does not seem to have evolved in significant ways. According to a recent poll by Deloitte, 68% of executives say data security and privacy are the areas most in need of improvement to accelerate blockchain implementation. Yet, it seems like privacy is far from being a paramount concern of crypto protocols.

From Pseudonymous to Public: The Transformation of Cryptocurrency Privacy

Despite the early emphasis on privacy in the nascent stages of cryptocurrencies, the trajectory of their evolution has been significantly influenced by a confluence of external factors. One of the primary influences has been regulatory pressures: with the meteoric rise in the popularity of cryptocurrencies and the consequential spotlight from investors and regulatory bodies, there has been a burgeoning need for these digital currencies to align with conventional financial protocols.

Many nations have mandated cryptocurrency exchanges to implement Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) procedures, consequently binding crypto wallets to tangible identities. This intertwining of the crypto world with real-world identities has been further exacerbated by the emergence of analytic companies. In response to the escalation in criminal enterprises utilizing cryptocurrencies, a slew of firms offering blockchain analytics services have surfaced.

Armed with the capability to dissect and decipher patterns in the blockchain, these companies possess the prowess to strip transactions of their anonymity, facilitating law enforcement agencies in tracking unauthorized activities. Additionally, the aspiration for cryptocurrencies to gain mainstream traction has necessitated their integration into the traditional financial fabric, an amalgamation that frequently demands a compromise on the very essence of crypto privacy.

The Current State of Privacy in Crypto

When it comes to privacy, there are two main groups that crypto breaks down into. First, there are coins built especially for privacy. Think of these as the digital equivalents of a secret diary. Monero, Zcash, and Dash lead this pack. Monero uses something called Ring Signatures, which is like sealing that diary with a special lock where you can confirm it’s locked without ever needing to open it. Zcash uses a technique named zk-SNARKs, which is like magic ink: you can confirm what’s written without actually seeing the text. Dash uses CoinJoin, where it’s as if multiple diary entries are jumbled together, making it hard to tell which entry belongs to whom.

Then, there’s the second group. These are popular coins like Bitcoin and Ethereum, which by default, are like open books. Anyone can read them. However, if users want, they can use tools to add some privacy to their transactions. It’s a bit like using a pen to scribble over some words in a book. Techniques like Coin Mixing blend multiple entries together, and platforms like Tornado Cash act as privacy shields for Ethereum.

But are these two approaches sufficient? Short answer is no. Here is why.

The main shortcomings of privacy coins is that they are often at the center of regulatory crosshairs, which makes it hard for users to feel confident in using them while they could become the target of a ban at any point. The apprehension of facing regulatory repercussions also prompts many exchanges to sidestep these coins, constricting their liquidity and curtailing their broader acceptance. And lastly, quite often privacy coins are not the most user friendly and are thus not likely to be used by a broad range of people.

When it comes to mainstream cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin and Ethereum, they offer users the option of enhancing privacy through tools like Coin Mixing and Tornado Cash. However, these tools provide only a veneer of anonymity. Specialized analytic firms, armed with advanced resources, have the capability to strip away this privacy layer and expose underlying transaction details. The onus to utilize these privacy-enhancing tools falls squarely on users, demanding not only their proactive engagement but also a certain degree of technical acumen — a barrier that can be daunting for many.

Further complicating matters, platforms like Ethereum levy additional gas fees for employing these privacy tools, making covert transactions pricier than their transparent counterparts. And despite the inherent transparency of these cryptocurrencies, the mere act of opting for enhanced privacy can attract the watchful eyes of regulators. Any stringent action on their part against these tools could further constrict the already limited avenues for user privacy.

Is there a Way Forward?

The future of privacy in cryptocurrencies is still up in the air, but a few trends are starting to stand out. First, we’re seeing more “layered” solutions like Bitcoin’s Lightning Network or Ethereum’s Rollups. These work like add-ons, potentially giving mainstream coins a privacy boost. Next, there’s the hope for clearer regulations worldwide. If governments can set consistent rules, both private and regular cryptocurrencies might find their own space to thrive. And, let’s not forget the power of users. If more people start demanding better privacy, the crypto world might just adapt to meet those needs.

About Cypherpunk Guild

The Cypherpunk Guild is a group of privacy-minded developers, marketers, and entrepreneurs, jointly collaborating to pioneer a future built around private transactions on NEAR Protocol and the larger crypto-verse. Led by two second-generation Cypherpunks, the Cypherpunk Guild supports the development of private applications on the Open Web, as a means of safeguarding user privacy and freedom.

Twitter | Website | Matrix | NEAR Forum

--

--

Cypherpunk Guild

Privacy is the power to selectively reveal oneself to the world.